We help resolve corporate disputes of any complexity.
We develop a strategy for the court proceedings.
We prepare recommendations and warn you about all the risks.
We take on even the most complex puzzles.
In the case of:
From the moment you sign an agreement with our firm, you have a whole team of attorneys specialising in registering, supporting and protecting businesses at your disposal.
How can we help?
Corporate relations depend heavily on court practice and the legal positions of the Supreme Court. Resolving a corporate dispute therefore requires an attorney who knows the current case law.
When we advise or go to court, we rely only on relevant positions and recent changes. This allows us to provide our clients with the most effective help.
When a lawyer from Radnyk Law Firm handles your corporate dispute, you can focus on your business without getting drawn into litigation or studying the specifics of the law and court practice.
In a broad sense, corporate disputes are conflicts of interest that arise between the participants of a company in the course of its business.
Corporate relations, and the disputes arising from them, are extremely diverse. According to the press service of the Supreme Court, the share of corporate disputes among the cases it hears has grown almost 30 times since 2012. Roughly every third case heard by the Commercial Cassation Court concerns a corporate dispute.
That is why corporate disputes in Ukraine are widely discussed at the highest judicial and legislative level.
Challenging a decision of the general meeting is an effective legal mechanism for protecting the right to take part in managing the company.
A corporate dispute in Ukraine can be resolved in only one way: by preparing a statement of claim (in some cases preceded by a claim letter) and filing it with a district court (in disputes involving heirs) or a commercial court (in all other cases).
Most often, corporate disputes concern decisions of the general meeting of participants that affect the interests of one of the participants.
Current court practice shows that any participant can defend their rights, regardless of the size of their share. However, a claim to invalidate a decision of the general meeting requires a violation of the claimant’s rights. In other words, if the decision does not affect the claimant’s interests in any way, the court will refuse protection.
When a general meeting decision is challenged, legal support for each side plays a decisive role. Whichever side you are on, claimant or defendant, we recommend getting help from an experienced corporate lawyer.
The procedure for holding a general meeting is governed by the laws on business companies and on limited and additional liability companies, and by the company’s charter.
Even seemingly minor violations can be grounds for declaring a general meeting decision invalid.
Please note: a claim to declare a general meeting decision invalid is subject to a one-year limitation period (clause 8, part 2, Article 258 of the Civil Code of Ukraine).
Even if a participant attended the meeting but was not properly notified, this is a violation and may be grounds for invalidating the decision: although present, the participant was deprived of the opportunity to prepare properly for the agenda.
Invalidation of a general meeting decision does not automatically restore the claimant’s rights, so the attorney’s role does not end with a favourable judgment. We provide further legal support with enforcement of the judgment, changes to the register, invalidation of transactions and so on.
Another common and difficult type of dispute concerns settlement between the company and a former participant who has withdrawn, or compensation to an heir who does not wish to become a participant.
The withdrawing participant’s share can be paid in money or, by agreement, in other property. The company must pay within one year from the day it learned or should have learned of the withdrawal, unless the charter sets a different term.
Meanwhile, a participant who has left an LLC is entitled to dividends declared before the withdrawal. Payment of the value of the share on withdrawal is not a reason to refuse such dividends.
Keep in mind that a former participant does not receive their original (nominal) contribution.
The value of the share is determined on the basis of the market value of all the participants’ shares together, in proportion to the size of that participant’s share.
That is why involving an attorney in this matter always means:
A Zaporizhzhia company came to us after a conflict arose between its participants and the heir of a deceased participant. The heir did not recognise the arrangements made between the founders and demanded payment for the deceased participant’s share by allocating premises to him in kind.
Our attorneys argued that property could not be allocated without the consent of the company itself. As a result, the claim was dismissed.
Case
Later the same heir went to court again, this time asking for payment for the share in money. Although the claim itself was lawful, the amount claimed was not objective: it was based solely on the value of the company’s assets and ignored its debts and loan obligations.
We therefore initiated additional valuation examinations to determine the company’s net assets. As a result, the compensation was reduced from UAH 345,000 to UAH 174,000.
Case
A similar situation arose when one of the participants decided to leave the company and demanded compensation for the share. As in the previous case, the claimed value did not correspond to the net assets, so we sought a recalculation.
Seven expert examinations were carried out to determine the compensation, and the proceedings lasted three years. Our client gained the time it needed for its business, and the real value of the compensation decreased significantly.
Case
A former LLC participant filed a claim with a civil court to cancel a number of transactions made after he left. At the same time, he asked the court to freeze all of the company’s property. The first-instance court, without fully examining the case, ordered the freeze of our client’s property, and we appealed.
As a result of our attorneys’ work, the freeze was refused and the proceedings were closed.
Case
A former participant sued our client, a limited liability company, asking the court to invalidate a decision of the general meeting and to cancel the state registration of real estate that had been sold.
Thanks to a well-built and consistent position, we not only persuaded the court to dismiss the claim but also recovered all of the client’s legal costs.
Case in the court register (first instance)
CaseResult: Claim granted in full. The commercial court ordered the supplier to return UAH 32,160 of prepayment for undelivered goods and to pay UAH 2,662.40 of court fee. The defendant's attempt to cover the shortfall with screenshots of Telegram correspondence was rejected.
A construction company from Zaporizhzhia turned to the lawyers of Radnyk Law Firm. The story is painfully typical. The firm paid for the manufacture of metal parts against the supplier’s invoices, received part of the order and was left waiting for the rest. It waited for more than a year. Then the supplier declared that […]
Result: Claim granted. The commercial court ordered the municipal enterprise to pay UAH 6,631,177.98 of debt for completed construction works and UAH 79,574.13 of court fee. The customer's attempt to revise the fixed contract price retroactively was rejected.
A construction company turned to the lawyers of Radnyk Law Firm. It had won a tender, laid a water supply network and commissioned the facility. Then the customer, a municipal enterprise of the city council, refused to sign the certificates of completed works and to pay. Almost seven million hryvnias were left hanging. Background: a […]
Result: The tax assessment notice for UAH 110,376 was declared unlawful and cancelled. The tax service's appeal was dismissed and the judgment has entered into force.
A company from Zaporizhzhia Region turned to us after the Main Directorate of the State Tax Service (STS) imposed a fine of more than UAH 110,000 following a desk audit. The ground was late registration of tax invoices and adjustment calculations in the Unified Register of Tax Invoices (URTI). The essence of the dispute In […]
Result: The client met its obligations to its counterparty and avoided a fine.
Blocking of tax invoices is one of the most acute problems for Ukrainian business. Often the tax authority does not simply suspend registration but also sends additional requests, demanding an explanation of the staffing table or the submission of inventory lists. Many business owners believe that if they do not answer such a request, or […]
We use cookies to keep the site working and to understand which pages are useful to visitors. Learn more