Tax authority fined a company over UAH 110,000 for late registration of tax invoices: court cancelled the fine, the tax service’s appeal was dismissed

A company from Zaporizhzhia Region turned to us after the Main Directorate of the State Tax Service (STS) imposed a fine of more than UAH 110,000 following a desk audit. The ground was late registration of tax invoices and adjustment calculations in the Unified Register of Tax Invoices (URTI).

The essence of the dispute

In March 2024 the STS carried out a desk audit and found that the company had registered six tax invoices issued in February and March 2022 only in September 2023, with a delay of 98 to 111 days. Violations were also found in respect of three adjustment calculations. As a result of the audit a tax assessment notice was issued with penalties of 40% of the VAT amount on each invoice.

The company disagreed with the tax authority’s position and went to court.

Our position

We built the defence along two independent lines.

The first concerned the tax invoices of February and March 2022. All six invoices had been issued to correct technical errors (a wrong date) in previously registered documents that had been submitted for registration on time and included in the returns for the relevant periods. Some of the invoices had in fact been issued again by mistake: registered invoices for the same transactions already existed.

Even if the court did not accept that argument, applying the 40% penalty rate was unlawful. Law No. 2876-IX, which entered into force in February 2023, substantially changed the way penalties are calculated. Since these invoices were registered after the law entered into force, it was its provisions that had to be applied, not those in force on the date the invoices were issued. The STS applied inflated rates without taking the new wording of the law into account.

The second line concerned the adjustment calculations. Two of the three adjustment calculations had been received from counterparties late. We provided the court with screenshots from the M.E.Doc system showing the exact dates on which the documents were received. Both calculations were sent for registration within two days of receipt, that is, within the prescribed period. There was no delay on the company’s part at all.

The court’s decision

The Zaporizhzhia District Administrative Court granted the claim in respect of the UAH 110,376 fine, declaring the tax assessment notice unlawful in that part and cancelling it. The court agreed that the STS had applied inflated penalty rates, ignoring Law No. 2876-IX. As regards the adjustment calculations, the court accepted the M.E.Doc screenshots as proper evidence of the date of receipt of a document and confirmed that the company had committed no violation. In addition, the court fee and the costs of legal assistance were recovered from the tax authority.

The STS filed an appeal, but in April 2026 the Third Administrative Court of Appeal dismissed it. The court confirmed that Law No. 2876-IX applies by the date of registration of the invoice, not by the date it was issued; this approach is consistent with the position of the Supreme Court. Screenshots from M.E.Doc are admissible evidence in line with the Supreme Court’s case law in similar cases.

The judgment has entered into force.

What VAT payers should know

Fines for late registration of tax invoices are one of the most common instruments of pressure used by the STS. But far from every tax assessment notice is lawful.

First, changed penalty rates have applied since February 2023, and their application depends on the date of registration, not the date the invoice was issued. Many fines imposed on invoices of 2022 that were registered later were calculated at inflated rates.

Second, if the delay with an adjustment calculation was caused by a counterparty that sent the document late, this is a ground for cancelling the fine in full. The main thing is to record the date the document was received.

If you have received a fine for missing the deadlines for registering tax invoices or adjustment calculations, do not hurry to pay it. Such decisions are successfully challenged in court.

The case in the court register: link.

The case was handled by the firm's attorneys. Prepared by: Denys Shtabovenko, attorney, managing partner, Radnyk Law Firm.

05.06.2026

Have a question or ready to arrange a meeting?

You can ask a question through the form on the website or contact us in any way convenient for you