Another blocked tax invoice registered through the court, even though the client did not answer the tax service’s request for additional documents

Blocking of tax invoices is one of the most acute problems for Ukrainian business. Often the tax authority does not simply suspend registration but also sends additional requests, demanding an explanation of the staffing table or the submission of inventory lists. Many business owners believe that if they do not answer such a request, or do not provide the documents in full, there is no chance of success.

The lawyers of Radnyk Law Firm proved the opposite in case No. 280/3169/25. We were able to defend the interests of a construction company in the Third Administrative Court of Appeal even though the tax officials had considered the client’s explanations insufficient.

The essence of the dispute: risk criteria and the tax service’s demands

The tax service suspended registration of three of our client’s invoices, referring to “point 1 of the Risk Criteria”: the volume of the supply allegedly exceeded the stock of goods. The company provided source documents and explanations, but the tax service’s commission went further.

The tax officials sent additional notices, demanding that the company:

  • explain the “mismatch of labour resources”;
  • provide inventory records indicating the specific places where the stocktaking was carried out.

The client provided part of the documents, but the tax authority treated this as “partial submission” and finally refused to register the invoices. It was this refusal that we challenged in court.

Legal position: why silence or refusal is not a ground for sanctions

In court we built the defence on several key arguments, which proved decisive:

  • Vague wording. The tax authority’s refusal contained only a general phrase about “failure to provide documents”. The tax service did not state which specific document was missing to confirm that the transaction was real.
  • Exceeding its powers. We proved that the demands to explain the number of employees or to provide internal inventory records have nothing to do with the specific business transaction. Checking the “reality” of a business is the task of documentary audits, not of invoice monitoring.
  • Proof of payment. Since the invoices were issued on the “first event” (receipt of a prepayment), the bank statements and the contract were sufficient to identify the transaction.

The outcome

The appeal court agreed with our arguments. In its ruling of 2 March 2026 the court noted that the tax authority has no right to demand whatever documents it sees fit if they do not relate directly to the blocked invoice.

The result: all the tax service’s decisions were declared unlawful and cancelled. The court ordered the State Tax Service of Ukraine to register the invoices in the Unified Register.

Takeaway for business owners

Even if you have received a notice of “insufficient documents”, or could not give the tax service everything it asked for, this is no reason to give up. Case law shows that the tax officials’ formal approach often does not stand up in court. The main thing is to record properly that the transaction was real and to point out the tax authority’s own procedural violations.

The case in the court register: link.

The case was handled by the firm's attorneys. Prepared by: Denys Shtabovenko, attorney, managing partner, Radnyk Law Firm.

13.03.2026

Have a question or ready to arrange a meeting?

You can ask a question through the form on the website or contact us in any way convenient for you