Supplier took the prepayment and did not ship the goods: commercial court awarded UAH 32,160 to the buyer
A construction company from Zaporizhzhia turned to the lawyers of Radnyk Law Firm. The story is painfully typical. The firm paid for the manufacture of metal parts against the supplier’s invoices, received part of the order and was left waiting for the rest. It waited for more than a year. Then the supplier declared that it had shipped everything down to the last part and, as proof, showed the court screenshots from a messenger.
Background: two invoices, full payment and half of the goods
The parties did not sign a contract as a single document. They worked the way a considerable part of Ukrainian business works: the supplier issued invoices, the buyer paid them, and the products were shipped in batches.
Against two invoices issued in December 2024 and January 2025 the client transferred UAH 98,400 by two payment orders. It actually received goods worth UAH 66,240. That amount was confirmed by delivery notes signed by both parties. The balance of UAH 32,160 stayed with the supplier.
The buyer sent a written demand to return the money. There was no reply, no money and no goods.
One separate point made the case neater. The claim was initially filed for UAH 39,360. After we reconciled all the registered tax invoices and separated the disputed supply from a separate arrangement on packaging of the goods, the claim was reduced to UAH 32,160. The court saw not “how much was asked for” but a verified calculation. This builds trust in the claimant’s position more effectively than any emotion in the courtroom.
The supplier’s position: “we shipped everything, you have the delivery notes”
The defendant built its defence on three pillars.
First, the goods were manufactured and handed over in full; the buyer simply did not return the signed delivery notes. Second, the accountant had sent those delivery notes to the buyer’s accountant via Telegram, and there was correspondence. Third, after confirming receipt of the parts the buyer’s representative stopped responding, so there were no complaints.
It sounded convincing, right up to the moment the court began to check it against the procedural standards of proof.
Legal basis: Article 693 of the Civil Code of Ukraine and a supply contract concluded in simplified form
The first thing to take off the agenda was the argument that no contract had been concluded. The court confirmed: the invoices issued, the payment orders for them and the signed delivery notes for the partial supply confirm that a supply contract was concluded in simplified form (Article 181 of the Commercial Code, Article 205 of the Civil Code of Ukraine). The absence of a paper contract with seals changes nothing.
Then Article 693 of the Civil Code of Ukraine applies. If the seller has received a prepayment and has not handed over the goods within the agreed period, the buyer is entitled to choose: to demand delivery of the paid goods or the return of the prepayment. The choice belongs to the buyer alone. The seller has no part in it.
The court separately stressed that the law does not prescribe the form of such a demand, so filing a claim is in itself a proper exercise of the right to the return of the prepayment. This position relies on the Supreme Court decision of 27 August 2019 in case No. 911/1958/18. An advance is returned to the party that paid it, regardless of whose fault it was that the obligation was not performed (decision of the Commercial Cassation Court within the Supreme Court of 21 February 2018 in case No. 910/12382/17).
Why the Telegram correspondence did not save the supplier
This was the key episode of the case. The defendant counted on screenshots replacing signed delivery notes.
The court approached the question without prejudice. Electronic correspondence is admissible in itself: the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court, in its ruling of 21 June 2023 in case No. 916/3027/21, stated directly that messages from messengers are electronic evidence and that a paper copy of such evidence does not automatically become inadmissible. But it is assessed together with the other evidence, and only if the court can establish the authors of the correspondence and its content.
This is where the defence fell apart. The court pointed to three defects: screenshots are not primary accounting documents; their content is not protected against editing and distortion; and the defendant did not prove that the person with whom the correspondence was conducted was employed by the buyer and was authorised to accept goods on the company’s behalf.
The conclusion is simple. Correspondence confirms a conversation, not a transfer of assets.
What the court decided
The court applied the standard of the balance of probabilities (Article 79 of the Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine). A circumstance is considered proven if the evidence in its favour is more convincing than the evidence against it.
The real movement of goods is confirmed by their actual transfer, not by the intention to ship them. The claimant had payment orders for UAH 98,400 and signed delivery notes for UAH 66,240. For the disputed amount the defendant had neither a signed delivery note, nor evidence of carriage, nor confirmation of the recipient’s authority. Nor did the defendant rebut the claimant’s arguments with other evidence, although it had the procedural opportunity to do so.
The claim was granted in full. The supplier was ordered to pay UAH 32,160 of prepayment and UAH 2,662.40 of court fee. The court postponed the question of allocating the costs of professional legal assistance until evidence of those costs is submitted under Part 8 of Article 129 of the Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine.
Practical takeaways for business
- Working on invoices without a signed contract does not deprive you of protection. An invoice, a payment order and a delivery note together form a supply contract.
- A delivery note without the buyer’s signature does not confirm delivery. Sending a scan to a messenger is not a handover of goods.
- If you are the supplier, record the authority of the person who accepts the goods: a power of attorney, an order, or at least a delivery note signed by an authorised person.
- If you are the buyer, send a written demand for the return of the prepayment before filing the claim. It fixes the moment you chose your remedy.
- Reducing the claim after reconciling the documents strengthens your position rather than weakening it.
Recovering a prepayment for undelivered goods: how we work
The lawyers of Radnyk Law Firm handle commercial disputes over debt recovery and the return of prepayments under supply contracts at every stage: pre-trial claims work, preparation of the claim and the calculation, representation in the commercial court, appeal and enforcement of the judgment.
If a counterparty has taken the money and is dragging out shipment, time is working against you: assets are moved out, the company is liquidated, limitation periods run. Come for a consultation while the money can still be recovered.
The case in the court register: link.
18.09.2026