Customer refused to sign the KB-2v certificate and pay for a completed water main: court awarded UAH 6.6 million to the contractor
A construction company turned to the lawyers of Radnyk Law Firm. It had won a tender, laid a water supply network and commissioned the facility. Then the customer, a municipal enterprise of the city council, refused to sign the certificates of completed works and to pay. Almost seven million hryvnias were left hanging.
Background: a tender, a fixed price and a commissioned facility
At the end of 2024 the municipal enterprise held an open tender (with special procurement rules) for the new construction of a water supply network. Our client won. The parties signed a construction contract under which the total price of the works was fixed at UAH 6,979,992.00.
The contractor carried out the works with its own materials, machinery and transport. The term of the contract was extended several times by supplementary agreements; the final date fell on 1 December 2025.
In November 2025 the contractor notified the customer that the works were complete. It attached the full set of documents: certificates of acceptance of completed construction works in form KB-2v, statements of the cost of completed works in form KB-3, the summary list of resources, the calculation of general production costs, the as-built documentation and the invoice.
The customer replied by letter: part of the as-built documentation was missing and the pipelines had not been disinfected. The contractor resolved the comments within three weeks. By 22 December 2025 the parties had signed a certificate on the elimination of defects and recorded that they had no claims against each other. The pipeline passed hydraulic strength and tightness tests. The customer signed the certificate of acceptance of the water supply network and confirmed that the facility had been built in accordance with the design documentation, standards and building codes.
The network was in operation. No payment followed.
How the customer tried to reduce the price retroactively
A week before the final certificates were handed over, the municipal enterprise sent a draft supplementary agreement reducing the contract price. Its justification was a report by a forensic commodity expert, according to which the cost of the material resources used had allegedly been overstated.
The customer’s position rested on two arguments. First, the actual volumes of work turned out to be smaller than those built into the contract price. Second, the contractor had used materials of other brands and from other countries of origin than those listed in Appendix No. 4 to the contract, “Information on prices of material resources”, and had decided on the substitution by itself.
The contractor refused to sign the supplementary agreement and sent a KB-2v certificate for UAH 6,631,177.98 signed unilaterally. The customer returned the documents unsigned. In its statement of defence it acknowledged a debt of only UAH 5,876,429.53.
The difference in the customer’s favour exceeded UAH 750,000.
The contractor’s position: three pillars of proof
A fixed price changes only by agreement of the parties. Under Article 844 of the Civil Code of Ukraine and the terms of the contract, the price was clearly defined, and changes are possible only by mutual agreement recorded in a supplementary agreement. The customer never obtained such an agreement. The law does not allow a unilateral revision of the price after the facility has been handed over.
The works were actually performed. We put into the case file documents signed by the customer itself: the certificate of acceptance of the water supply network, the certificate on the elimination of defects and the results of the hydraulic tests. Each of them confirmed that the construction had taken place and confirmed its quality.
Replacing materials with equivalents was expressly permitted by the contract. Appendix No. 4 contained a list of items for which a material resource could be replaced with an equivalent. These were exactly the items the customer held against the contractor.
What the court decided
The court applied Part 4 of Article 882 of the Civil Code of Ukraine and the settled legal position of the Joint Chamber of the Commercial Cassation Court within the Supreme Court of 6 December 2019 in case No. 910/7446/18. Its essence is this: the handover and acceptance of works on the basis of a unilaterally signed certificate creates rights and obligations for the parties if the works under the contract were actually performed and the contractor did not receive a reasoned refusal to accept them within the established period.
The court then reasoned step by step.
The reality of the business transaction was proven. The customer confirmed with its own signature that the water supply network had been built according to the design and met the acceptance requirements. The pipeline passed the strength and tightness tests. The defects were eliminated and the parties had no claims against each other.
The absence of the customer’s signature on the KB-2v certificate does not in itself release it from payment. Legal consequences arise from the business transaction, that is, from the actual performance of the works. The source document is secondary to it.
The use of equivalents did not contradict the contract, since Appendix No. 4 expressly allowed such a substitution.
The expert report on which the customer relied both in correspondence and in its statement of defence was assessed critically by the court: the case file contained no corresponding evidence.
The outcome: UAH 6,631,177.98 of debt for completed works plus UAH 79,574.13 of court fee.
The court refused the claim for the return of UAH 34,899.96 paid as contract performance security. The case file contained no evidence of payment.
Practical takeaways for contractors and customers
A unilateral KB-2v certificate works. If the customer stays silent or refuses to sign without clear reasons, the certificate signed by the contractor becomes the basis for recovering the debt under the construction contract through the court. The main condition is to prove that the works were actually performed.
Interim documents decide the outcome of the case. The certificate of acceptance of the facility, the test report, the certificate on the elimination of defects, the correspondence about readiness for handover. Every signature of the customer on such a document later closes off its path to denying that the works were done.
A fixed price protects the contractor. A reference to an expert assessment of the cost of materials does not give the customer the right to cut the agreed amount unilaterally. If it wants to lower the price, it has to negotiate and sign a supplementary agreement.
Read the appendix on material resources before signing the contract. In this case the wording on the admissibility of equivalents cost the customer its entire main argument. Check for which items substitution is allowed and record it in writing.
Claim only what is supported by documents. The claim for the return of the security was rejected not because it was unlawful, but because the payment evidence and the pre-trial correspondence never made it into the case file.
Recovering debt under a construction contract: help from an attorney in Zaporizhzhia
A customer’s refusal to sign the certificate of completed works is among the most frequent conflicts in construction contracting. This is especially true in public procurement, where the manager of budget funds fears claims from the supervisory authorities and prefers to hold back payment.
The lawyers of Radnyk Law Firm handle commercial disputes under construction contracts at every stage: pre-trial claims work, preparation of a unilateral certificate, a claim for payment for completed construction works, appeal and enforcement proceedings. We work with contractors, subcontractors and customers on projects of any complexity.
Is the customer not paying for completed works? Contact us for a consultation and we will assess the prospects of recovery on the basis of your documents.
The case in the court register: link.
30.07.2026