A dispute has arisen under a lease, works or services contract?
We help resolve any contract dispute, from the claim letter to a court judgment in your favour.
We handle the process, you deal only with the outcome.
Clients often ask us as attorneys whether they should go to court or wait and try to settle the contract dispute out of court.
For 20 years, contract litigation in Ukrainian courts has been one of our attorneys’ main practice areas. We give priority to resolving contract disputes in court, because going to court is the most reliable way to resolve the problem and protect our clients’ interests.
To assess a dispute arising from a contract, the first step is a legal analysis of the contract itself: checking that it complies with the law and studying its essential terms, the agreed liability and so on.
After reviewing the contract, the attorney can assess the prospects of the case and give practical recommendations on how to resolve the problem.
Apart from reaching a compromise and settling the dispute before trial, a contract dispute in Zaporizhzhia (and in Ukraine generally) can be resolved in only one way: by preparing and filing a statement of claim (in some cases preceded by a claim letter) with a district (general) or commercial court.
When you instruct Radnyk Law Firm, your own involvement in the case is kept to a minimum.
Our attorney can handle a contract dispute in two ways:
Each stage is paid for separately.
We agree a fee for handling the whole case, from filing the documents with the court to obtaining the judgment.
It is practically impossible to quote an exact fee without knowing the substance of your problem and seeing the contract. The fee is therefore agreed at the first consultation and set out in the legal services agreement.
How long a contract dispute takes depends largely on the specifics of the case, the court’s workload and whether expert examinations are needed. If the issue is not legally complex and the court practice on it is settled, it usually takes no more than 6 months.
Indicative list of documents needed to prepare a claim under a contract and file it with a court in Zaporizhzhia
Using these documents, our attorney will prepare the claim, calculate all available penalties and prepare the documents needed to recover the attorney’s fees from the debtor as court costs.
A contract is binding on the parties (unless its terms directly contradict the law), so each party must strictly comply with it. A unilateral refusal to perform the obligations undertaken leads to contractual liability.
Contractual liability arises where two conditions are met:
Contractual liability for the party in breach may include:
You can ask a question through the form on the website or contact us in any way convenient for you
First of all, voidable contracts must be distinguished from void ones (nikchemni). A voidable contract has to be declared invalid by a court, while a void contract does not need to be declared invalid because it contradicts mandatory requirements for that type of contract (for example, a sale of real estate concluded in simple written form without notarization).
When you file a claim to invalidate a contract, you will have to prove specific facts showing that your rights and interests were violated.
Grounds for invalidating a contract include:
Together with the claim to invalidate the contract, the claimant may ask the court to apply the consequences of invalidity (return of the money paid, return of property and so on).
In today’s world, where one crisis follows another, termination of contracts by court has become particularly relevant. Most often, parties go to court to terminate land lease agreements.
Grounds for termination by court include:
The party seeking termination must show a significant change of circumstances that it could not have known about before concluding the contract. Because of such changes, it cannot satisfy its financial or other interests, so the contract can no longer be performed as it no longer reflects the parties’ original agreement and intentions at the time of signing.
You are not always the party that starts the proceedings, recovers a debt or seeks to invalidate a contract.
You need protection in a contract dispute when a claim letter or a lawsuit relating to a contract you have concluded is brought against you.
In that case our attorney will help you with:
Our client handled communications related to the employment of foreign nationals. One of his counterparties regularly used these services and transferred money to our client’s account. Later a disagreement arose, and a claim was brought against our client for recovery of money allegedly received without legal grounds. The claim argued that since there was no written contract between the parties, all the money transferred had been received without grounds.
As evidence of the contractual relationship we used Viber correspondence in which the parties repeatedly discussed the terms, deadlines and procedure of the work.
As a result, the first-instance and appellate courts dismissed the claim.
CaseA client came to us with a dispute under a works contract. During 2020 the client’s company performed works worth more than UAH 1,500,000, but the customer paid only part of the price and refused to pay the rest.
We compiled the documents proving that the works had been performed and filed a claim with a court in Kherson. Notably, we took part in the hearings by video link, which significantly reduced the client’s time and costs.
As a result, the court not only recovered the debt of UAH 1,000,000 but also ordered the debtor to pay UAH 29,161.39 of penalty and UAH 7,290.35 of 3% per annum for breach of the contract.
CaseDisputes under services contracts require a special approach to evidence and legal strategy, especially when it comes to security services.
In this case the customer refused to pay for the security services it had received, citing invented shortcomings.
A properly compiled set of documents and a well-chosen legal position allowed us to resolve the dispute in 2 months: the debt was recovered in full, and the debtor was ordered to pay contractual penalties and all legal costs, including the attorney’s fees.
CaseResult: Claim granted in full. The commercial court ordered the supplier to return UAH 32,160 of prepayment for undelivered goods and to pay UAH 2,662.40 of court fee. The defendant's attempt to cover the shortfall with screenshots of Telegram correspondence was rejected.
A construction company from Zaporizhzhia turned to the lawyers of Radnyk Law Firm. The story is painfully typical. The firm paid for the manufacture of metal parts against the supplier’s invoices, received part of the order and was left waiting for the rest. It waited for more than a year. Then the supplier declared that […]
Result: Claim granted. The commercial court ordered the municipal enterprise to pay UAH 6,631,177.98 of debt for completed construction works and UAH 79,574.13 of court fee. The customer's attempt to revise the fixed contract price retroactively was rejected.
A construction company turned to the lawyers of Radnyk Law Firm. It had won a tender, laid a water supply network and commissioned the facility. Then the customer, a municipal enterprise of the city council, refused to sign the certificates of completed works and to pay. Almost seven million hryvnias were left hanging. Background: a […]
Result: The tax assessment notice for UAH 110,376 was declared unlawful and cancelled. The tax service's appeal was dismissed and the judgment has entered into force.
A company from Zaporizhzhia Region turned to us after the Main Directorate of the State Tax Service (STS) imposed a fine of more than UAH 110,000 following a desk audit. The ground was late registration of tax invoices and adjustment calculations in the Unified Register of Tax Invoices (URTI). The essence of the dispute In […]
Result: The client met its obligations to its counterparty and avoided a fine.
Blocking of tax invoices is one of the most acute problems for Ukrainian business. Often the tax authority does not simply suspend registration but also sends additional requests, demanding an explanation of the staffing table or the submission of inventory lists. Many business owners believe that if they do not answer such a request, or […]
A company came to us that had paid 100% in advance for a delivery of special-purpose clothing from a supplier. The goods were never delivered, and the supplier ignored written demands. Our attorneys prepared a notice terminating the supply contract and demanding the prepayment back, and then filed a claim for recovery of the money and penalties. Result: the court granted the claim, despite the defendant’s attempts to prove that it had notified the buyer that the goods were ready for shipment. Case in the court register: http://www.reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/39988551
Our regular client had a contract with a printing house to print a newspaper. Under the contract, the print run had to be produced within the agreed time after the layout was delivered. However, because the printing house disagreed with the content of the issue, it did not print the run, and the client had to move the printing to another printing house. Our attorneys collected evidence of the breach and filed a claim with the Commercial Court of Zaporizhzhia Region. Result: the court granted the claim, despite the defendant’s attempts to prove that the breach was not its fault. Case in the court register: http://www.reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/26385550
We were approached by an entrepreneur who installs PVC windows. For more than a year he had been trying to get the final payment after installing windows in a customer’s flat, but the customer, claiming that the windows were of poor quality, refused either to pay for them or to return them. The entrepreneur had filed the claim himself, but the court could not finish hearing the case on the merits. Our attorneys clarified the claims, made proper calculations of the penalties and submitted additional evidence that the customer had breached the contract. Result: the court granted the claim, despite the defendant’s attempts to prove that the breach was not his fault, that he had paid the full price at once and that the products were defective. Case in the court register: http://www.reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/51954911
We use cookies to keep the site working and to understand which pages are useful to visitors. Learn more