Court ordered Ukrainian Railways to pay UAH 2.9 million of debt

Before the full-scale war began, our client had won a tender of Ukrainian Railways (Ukrzaliznytsia) for the repair of a rail motor car. Under the tender terms our client had to complete the repair entirely at its own expense and only then receive payment.

The repair was substantially delayed, however, because the client’s production base was located in territory that was occupied in the first days of the war. Nevertheless, the company managed to complete the repair and handed the vehicle over to the customer under an acceptance certificate.

Instead of paying for the repair, the railway filed a claim for a fine and late-performance penalty. Our client, in turn, came to us to file a claim for recovery of the debt.

We filed a claim with the Commercial Court of the City of Kyiv, asking it to award the debt, penalties and attorney costs.

The defendant did not admit the claim. In its view the cost of the works was overstated, the works were of poor quality, and the certificates it had signed had allegedly also been signed incorrectly.

The court, however, accepted our arguments that signing the certificate of completed works is evidence that the works were performed, and that the defendant’s conduct met the criteria of the prohibition of contradictory behaviour.

The court therefore granted the claim in full.

The case in the court register: link.

The case was handled by the firm's attorneys. Prepared by: Denys Shtabovenko, attorney, managing partner, Radnyk Law Firm.

24.05.2024

Have a question or ready to arrange a meeting?

You can ask a question through the form on the website or contact us in any way convenient for you