Debt recovered from a sanctioned company through the court

The essence of the case

In this commercial dispute our firm went to court on the client’s behalf, seeking to recover from the counterparty, the Sumy plant of pump and power engineering “Nasosenergomash”, a debt for goods supplied. Under the supply contract the supplier delivered goods worth UAH 157,394.15, but the defendant did not pay for them on time. In addition to the debt, we also claimed inflation losses, interest for the delay and court costs.

The opposing party referred to the difficulties that arose during hostilities and to force majeure circumstances that allegedly prevented performance of the obligation (the imposition of sanctions on the plant). These arguments, however, did not change the court’s position.

How the proceedings developed

The case was heard under the simplified commercial procedure. The court examined the case file, the supply contract, the delivery certificates and delivery notes confirming the transfer of the goods, and the counterparty’s statement of defence.

The key point was the confirmation of delivery and non-payment: the documents drawn up by the parties consistently showed that the goods had been delivered and accepted but not paid for on time. The defendant provided no evidence of payment and could not show any grounds for release from liability.

The court based its conclusions on the provisions of the Civil Code of Ukraine, in particular those on the proper performance of obligations, the consequences of delay and liability for late performance of monetary obligations.

The court’s decision

The Commercial Court of Sumy Region granted the claim in full and ordered the defendant to pay:

  • debt for the goods supplied: UAH 157,394.15,
  • 3% per annum for the period of delay: UAH 16,998.57,
  • inflation losses: UAH 74,483.86,
  • court fee: UAH 2,986.52,
  • costs of professional legal assistance: UAH 7,000.00.

The total amount awarded thus exceeded UAH 248,000, a tangible commercial result for the client.

Why the court rejected the force majeure arguments

The court examined in detail the defendant’s arguments that the war period and changes in the economic environment had prevented performance. However, under the legal position confirmed by the case law of the Supreme Court, force majeure releases a party from liability only in respect of accessory obligations, those that derive from the principal obligation, such as inflation losses and interest for the delay. Such obligations follow the principal one and share its fate. But even here the defendant did not prove the existence of force majeure.

The court concluded that the absence of the debtor’s fault in missing the deadline does not release it from the duty to compensate the economic consequences of the delay, since this is expressly provided for by the law and the contract.

What matters for business

This case highlights several practical points:

  • precise contractual terms on payment and delivery are important;
  • delivery documents must be properly drawn up and signed by the counterparty;
  • recovery of accrued interest and inflation losses can succeed even when the counterparty refers to difficult external circumstances.

The case in the court register: link.

The case was handled by the firm's attorneys. Prepared by: Denys Shtabovenko, attorney, managing partner, Radnyk Law Firm.

16.01.2026

Have a question or ready to arrange a meeting?

You can ask a question through the form on the website or contact us in any way convenient for you